Medicare Monday: One-size-fits-all treatments are wrong for patients

Allyson Funk
Allyson Funk April 25, 2016

Medicare Monday: One-size-fits-all treatments are wrong for patients.

Share This

MedMon_Catalyst_Banner.jpgThe government is proposing dramatic changes to Medicare Part B, including possible cuts to physician reimbursement for many innovative treatments based on the government’s decisions about which treatments are most valuable for seniors. Unfortunately, these decisions would be based on average results across broad populations, ignoring individual patient needs.  

As a result, patients who don’t fit the average, like Simon, may have difficulty gaining access to the treatment best for them.  For a patient like Simon, diagnosed with late stage and rapidly advancing colorectal cancer, the specific course of treatment has real implications. Simon’s tumor has a specific genetic variant (wild type KRAS), which means he is more likely to respond to specific targeted treatments. Not all treatments are the same, and for Simon, the specific treatment matters.


Assuming that patients should be treated on an average ignores the needs of individual patients, and Simon’s case study is just one example of how this could happen under the government’s proposal.

Download Simon’s profile as a PDF here, and visit other case studies like Simon at PhRMA.org/casestudy

Learn more at PhRMA.org/PartB.

Topics: Medicare, Medicare Monday, Part B